Originally Posted by AGS
Not. me. At $1,900 it's not worth it. Never lost a tire/rim on either of my E60s (***knock wood***). Also, I confirmed with my insurance company that tire & wheel replacement due to road hazards (such as potholes) are covered under my collision insurance.
I'm in the same boat, my sales guy recommended it heavily. But of the last 5 cars I've owned, all with 19" wheels or better, I've lost one tire. Not worth it IMO.