BMW Garage BMW Meets Register Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Go Back   M5POST - BMW M5 Forum > F10 M5 Forum > BMW M5 (F10) General Forum

Post Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
      11-05-2012, 12:25 PM   #1

Drives: 2002 M5/2013 M5 6MT
Join Date: Jun 2012
Location: San Diego

iTrader: (0)

New - 2013 BMW M5 Manual Transmission Review

2013 BMW M5 Manual Transmission Review

After 600 miles in the 2013 M5, your concept of automotive reality gets bent a little. And itís not just the enthusiast thatís affected. My three year old daughter (unassisted) proclaimed it ďthe MachineĒ after the M5′s third day in the driveway. Then there were the neighbors I hadnít spoken to in years who made their way over to check out the orange beast. And thatís just due to the carís presence. Once behind the wheel of the 562 hp ďMachineĒ one starts to lose grip on what is and isnít possible when exploring the appropriate limits on deserted roads. Something modern fast cars tend to do as they make speed more and more unremarkable. But this particular M5 is different. It wears its soul proudly on its sleeve in the form of the (North American exclusive) six speed manual sitting in the middle of the console. A bit of old school in a sea of technology acronyms. A purposeful flaw in a car designed and engineered to be perfectó and is made all the more loveable for the addition. Weíve done track time in both the DCT and manual previously so with this week-long test we wanted to throw the real world at the M5. Commuting, child-seats (Recaros of course) and even a road trip thrown in for good measure. But our first experience was what this car was made for. I first locked eyes on our Sakhir Orange M5 at the OíHare valet after stepping off a flight. Its first task? Making use of those 562hp and four doors to transport business colleagues to the office and then out to dinner. Heated seats and supreme comfort all around, the M5 tackled the thick Chicago traffic and driving rainstorm as well as any luxury car could. And when asked, it of course entertained the crowd with a few opposite-lock theatrics. This is the polarity that has defined the M5 since the 80′s E28. Equally effective as executive transport or as track weapon, the M5 has been refined over the past three decades to the point of near perfect. With the 2013 F10M M5, BMW has further refined the concept of a four door sports car into something that feels almost impossible to fault. Until of course you step back and realize that any fault may lie in the perfection itself.

Enter the Manual: Putting the M Back in M5
Letís get one thing clear. We like the M-DCT transmission in the current M3, M5 and M6. It does everything a modern flappy-paddle gearbox should with quick shifts, matching revs and seven ratios to play with. Itís faster and more efficient than a manual could ever me. Yet we were ecstatic when we managed to snag one of the rare manual M5s BMW had for the press. For one, itís a dying breed and likely the last time weíll see a manual offered in an M5. Thatís us and not BMW talking. But itís pretty easy to read between the lines when you realize that this transmission is only being offered in one market and they expect take rates to be decidedly lower than the previous M5. And it makes sense. Itís a flawed piece of technology compared to the M-DCT. Itís flawed because of its connection to the driver. Exactly why I loved it drive after drive. Yet it wasnít love at first shift. It took a couple of days to gel with the light clutch which, after seven days, still felt at odds with the character of the car. But eventually I did come to terms with it and the sweet shifting six speed (a transmission thatís much less notchy than the one found in the current M3). The engagement point of the clutch was easy to find and power easy to modulate. And the ability to heel to toe, blip the throttle and quickly go from 4th to 3rd, 3rd to 2nd was all there.

With the new M5′s manual, BMW also introduced rev matching on downshift. For example, if you go from 4th to 3rd the engine will blip the throttle to match the revs ensuring a perfect transition from one gear to the next. Itís a cool feature but one that you have to get used to if youíre someone who enjoys doing the dance yourself. The rev-match occurs for all downshifts (and double de-clutch downshifts) from gears 5 to 1, except when SPORT+ engine mode is selected. As M fans know, SPORT+ is where the fun lies but it is now also the ďblip it yourselfĒ mode. And yes itís defeat-able by turning all electronic aids off as well. For more on the manual M5 and its on-track habits, be sure to check out Michaelís review of the car at Laguna Seca.

562 hp of Engine
Weíve reviewed this engine before in the M5, M6 and the engine itís based on (the S63) in the X5 and X6 M twins. Itís big, heavy, laden with turbos (inside the ďVĒ no less) and has a massive cooling system to keep it all in check.

But letís look at some figures to better understand how the complexity of this powerplant creates simplicity on the road.

The all aluminum 4.4L twin scroll twin turbo engine has a 10.0:1 compression ratio to start with. But BMW M wanted a faster revving and more responsive engine while maintaining the incredible drivability of the S63. So they doubled the size of the intercoolers and added Valvetronic. This effectively gives the S63TŁ 16 intake throttles.

M went the route of increasing efficiency by 30% rather than upping the power over the S63 in the X5M/X6M. That, coupled with the increased capacity of the now metal fuel tank, has increased range dramatically over the E60 M5.

The Secret Sauce of M
In the previous M5, the variable differential lock was controlled by the speed differential between the drive wheels. Basically a passive system activated by different wheel speeds. With the new M differential the M5 engages the diff proactively by means of an electric motor with downstream transmission and ball ramp. Itís a faster, more efficient system that almost felt like it could see the future in its reflexes. The diff combined with the suspension and general reflexes managed to make the M5 feels smaller than it is. And it seemed to shrink the more and more I pushed it. But crucially it also felt completely toss-able even at low-speeds Ė not something many a 4,354 lbs car can achieve. Oh and you can lay down some serious black marks as well. But all the smokey burn-outs in the world can only get you so far. Eventually you will find yourself in the twisties. Here the M5 delivers in spite of its 200 lbs weight gain over the previous car. Unlike the E60, the F10M isnít dominated by an engine. Itís much more like the E39 in that it feels like the sum of fantastic ingredients.

First we start with a steering that is communicative, thanks to being hydraulic rather than electronic like the series production car. Naturally weíre not talking E28 or even E39 levels of communication. But when pushed, the F10M will subtly shrink around you. Whether itís hustling through traffic or around a corner at a track the M5 will allow you to place it in a precise fashion with confidence. Compared with other 4,000 lbs super saloons thatís saying something. The suspension is of course variable with three settings. In general I found comfort allowed too much body motion and allowed less information back to the driver. Sport was spot-on for normal roads and Sport + gave up some comfort for a rigid, more controlled experience.

I found the steering (also with three settings) was a bit different. While Sport + gave you a heavier more purposeful resistance, it was the middle setting of Sport that seemed to deliver the right balance between more feel and the right amount of weight. On-center all felt great and neither seemed out of character like the suspensionís comfort mode.

Finally thereís throttle response. Letís throw comfort out immediately because once you get used to either Sport or Sport + you can modulate your right foot to allow for plenty of comfort as required. The main difference between Sport and Sport + in the real world was that the surprisingly effective ďauto blipĒ of the throttle on downshift isnít operational on the latter. Call it a gimmick but I grew to love the consistency and predictability of the auto blip and therefore stuck it in Sport during normal driving.

All of this technology of course affects the three primary connection points with the driver; throttle, steering and shifting gears. With the DCT Iím left feeling like Iím a cog in the wheel of the ďMachine.Ē In our manual equipped test car, I felt I was the brains and the muscle behind it all. Itís easy to dismiss the DCT as less than involving but Iím not so sure thatís 100% true. Itís a different kind of involving. The manual brings your focus to a difference level of engagement. Thereís more to master. Thereís more to solve. And yes, thereís more to worry about. But the satisfaction of getting it wrong, and then right, allowed for a connection with the driving experience and the car that I wouldnít have otherwise had.

Perfection That Isnít Perfect
The M5 (gasp) isnít perfect. In the US the M5 isnít available with adjustable side bolsters (the kind I have on my 535ix wagon for Godís sake) and the manual is derived from the 550iís and thus has a clutch feel thatís put to shame by a $20K MINI. And the elephant in the room (pun intended) is the fact that this is a big car. 4,354 lbs Big. As the 5 Series has grown, the intimacy with road has decreased in the M5. Yet the M5 delivers in all the ways it has since the E28. It provides the ultimate fast sedan experience by bridging the gap of racetrack to office better than any car Iíve ever driven. It can do opulent almost as well as it can hoon. In the real world this is a car that feels utterly invincible and yes, machine like. It may not deliver the pure M experience of a 1M or M3. But it does deliver on its promise to be the best sports sedan on the planet if you want driver involvement and real feedback to go along with the expected healthy dose of speed. Weíve confirmed it on the track and now we can confirm on the road. The ďMachineĒ is still king.
Appreciate 0
      11-05-2012, 12:51 PM   #2
Big K...
uhn2000's Avatar

Drives: FerrariFF
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Toronto, Ontario

iTrader: (0)

Interesting review..
Prancing horse..
Appreciate 0
      11-05-2012, 01:14 PM   #3
Major General
RPiM5's Avatar

Drives: Mexico Blue F10 M5(Mika)
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Sunny San Diego

iTrader: (0)

I wonder how many more 6spd manual reviews we are going to have? I read the whole thing, and it is wonderfully written, but there's basically nothing new to report. Yes we know the M5, is still King, yes we know the 6spd manual is for the American die hard old school enthusiast (aka Baby Boomer Generation), but what is really going on here? He did mention lack of adjustable side bolsters, which I was surprised to read about because I've never seen a review mention this before. No car is perfect, so long as there are humans to review it.
Appreciate 0
Post Reply


Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:19 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.0
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
1Addicts.com, BIMMERPOST.com, E90Post.com, F30Post.com, M3Post.com, ZPost.com, 5Post.com, 6Post.com, 7Post.com, XBimmers.com logo and trademark are properties of BIMMERPOST