View Single Post
      10-05-2012, 08:48 PM   #150
Racer Louis
Enlisted Member
United_States
11
Rep
38
Posts

Drives: 2019 M5
Join Date: Sep 2012
Location: California

iTrader: (0)

If it weren't so sad many of the comments made would be humorous. People are making assumptions without knowing what they're talking about and then try to treat their assumptions as facts. After treating their unsupported assumption as a fact they go off the deep end!

I don't think anybody here knows what BMW is trying to do to fix the problem let alone know what BMW's motivation is. Some comments indicate that the writer believes that BMW has singled them out so BMW could make an extra effort to make their life miserable. If that were the case, based upon how some have described their behavior, I wouldn't blame BMW -- but I don't think BMW would waste its time and the extra effort!

But as long as we're making assumptions and treating them as facts I'll tell you what I think. I think BMW is trying its best to get pumps that are not available in sufficient quantities to meet demand to dealers and VPCs in a fair and equitable manner. To do this they have kept track, by VIN, of each car that will have its pump replaced. According to the recall list, all but a handfull of cars are identified with a specific dealer. Some are cars that have already been delivered to customers, some are European Delivery cars and are on their way to the U. S. (including mine) and some may be cars purchased by a dealer for their own stock and haven't been sold to a customer yet. I think BMW is allocating the available pumps on a pro-rata basis based upon the number of cars each dealer has on the recall list. They'll do this until supply catches up with demand. This is the way they treat all dealers fairly so one dealer doesn't get all the pumps he needs and a nearby dealer that needs pumps doesn't get any. It's the same way BMW NA allocates new models to dealers. When a dealer actually gets the pumps BMW has shipped is also influenced by factors more under the control of the shipping process than BMW.

The only relationship to a VIN is to know how many pumps each dealer needs. Remember, you can't buy a car from BMW, you can only buy a new BMW from a dealer. If a dealer has 8 cars on the recall list and receives 5 pumps in the intial batch the dealer decides which cars they go on. BMW sells cars to dealers, not us. For this reason BMW NA can't tell the dealer which car to put them on, BMW doesn't own the car (or the dealership for that matter). All BMW knows and can do is recognize how many cars it sold to each dealer that need their pump replaced and send that dealer that many pumps as soon as it can. It appears to me (an assumption, not a fact) that is what BMW is doing.

I now turn this program back to the fiction writers!
Appreciate 0