Autocar Video Review of 2012 F10 M5... Still a Proper Lunatic's Car!

[Sedan_Clan]

Originally Posted by Remonster

If that's what it sounds like inside without active sound, then I'm sold...and a bit confused as to why we needed active sound at all, but maybe it was on and he didn't even know about it? Seems like something Sutcliffe would have mentioned.

Agreed x2!

Originally Posted by Ateam

I do not really buy that it feels like a veyern in acceleration. We are talking twice the hp in a veyern and not much more weight.

Don't take it so literally!

[TK-421]

I don't think he knew about the Active Sound Shit. I loved this car before I knew about that "feature" - it's like the soul of the car (and slowly M division) is gone. It looks like a fantastic car aside from that but that's a hell of a lot of money for a 5er.

[m balla]

It's like half a veyron w more doors... mos def gonna burn through back tires every 20 clicks... wonder what it will be like w awd... sign me up

[Sedan_Clan]

Originally Posted by TK-421

I don't think he knew about the Active Sound Shit. I loved this car before I knew about that "feature" - it's like the soul of the car (and slowly M division) is gone. It looks like a fantastic car aside from that but that's a hell of a lot of money for a 5er.

I reckon that he did (..conjecture either way we slice it), and it was either not equipped with the option or it was disabled. How could someone like him - an individual who reviews automobilies for a living - NOT know about the option? The interior of the cabin was quiet.

If you compare 1:32-1:36-ish of this Autocar video to the video on this link (..pay close attention to 0:22-0:30), the Active Sound is noticeably louder and more pronounced, especially in the higher rev range. The car that Steve was driving was not this loud at WOT.

[dlbrooks18]

Nice review, awesome job BMW!

[Remonster]

Originally Posted by Sedan_Clan

I reckon that he did (..conjecture either way we slice it), and it was either not equipped with the option or it was disabled. How could someone like him - an individual who reviews automobilies for a living - NOT know about the option? The interior of the cabin was quiet.

Are you serious? Auto journalists FREQUENTLY don't know the car they are driving from a cup of coffee. They often spout off incorrect facts and specifications. On top of that, most reviewers I've seen (particularly the American magazines) are absolutely awful drivers.

With that said, Autocar is one of my favorites and I respect Sutcliffe and consider him among the best so if we're talking about him in particular, I do think he would have taken the time to find out what options and features the car he was driving had.

Active sound aside, and I'm sure it can be turned off anyways, I'm really glad he liked it. The M5 is almost a perfect car if you ask me.

[Sedan_Clan]

Originally Posted by Remonster

Are you serious? Auto journalists FREQUENTLY don't know the car they are driving from a cup of coffee. They often spout off incorrect facts and specifications. On top of that, most reviewers I've seen (particularly the American magazines) are absolutely awful drivers.

With that said, Autocar is one of my favorites and I respect Sutcliffe and consider him among the best so if we're talking about him in particular, I do think he would have taken the time to find out what options and features the car he was driving had.

Active sound aside, and I'm sure it can be turned off anyways, I'm really glad he liked it. The M5 is almost a perfect car if you ask me.

Yes, my entire post was in reference to Sutcliffe specifically......

....thus, we agree!

[Frosty]

Originally Posted by JimmyT

"...a proper lunatics car..." sign me up!!

+1!

[dpwr]

damn, now I need my stocks to triple and I'll get one

[Jonny550]

Was anyone else aroused by the turbo squeal?

[a.m.alkuwaiti]

great review, seeking for more

[ORIGIN M.]

"...a proper lunatics car..."

[Whostheboss]

Originally Posted by Questforpower

Other than the steering arguements, I want one... someone please give me $90K.

[BMWPower06]

Absolutely epic. Where do I sign up?!